Vegetarian Thanksgiving Menu, 5 Sides and 2 Mains

Share:

Five sides, two mains, and one dessert make a complete vegetarian Thanksgiving menu that one oven and one stovetop can carry to the table hot.

Once the turkey leaves the center of the table, the rest of the meal does not close ranks on its own. What replaces it is a menu with a center, built course by course, rather than a set of vegetarian Thanksgiving dishes that happen to share a table. That difference decides whether your vegetarian guests sit down to a plate that was planned or one that was assembled from whatever had no meat in it.

Five sides, two mains, one dessert. Two mains carry more weight than the side count, because one of them has to hold the middle of the table the way a roast does, and the other has to answer the guest who wanted something carved. The five sides are then chosen against those two mains instead of piled up around them, and the whole build runs on a cooking schedule that starts three days out.

At a Glance

• Five sides, two mains, one dessert is the shape: enough abundance to read as Thanksgiving, few enough dishes to cook every one of them well.
• Main one is the carved centerpiece, a whole pumpkin stuffed with rice, vegetables, cranberries, and nuts, then roasted in its own shell.
• Main two is the turkey alternative, a wild rice and mushroom stuffed acorn squash, plated one half per guest.
• The five vegetarian Thanksgiving sides are stuffing, sweet potatoes, roasted brussels sprouts, glazed carrots, and fresh cranberry sauce.
• Stuffing and gravy are the two dishes that quietly are not vegetarian, and mushroom stock fixes both.
• Cooking on this Thanksgiving vegetarian menu starts three days out, and only the final two hours ask the oven to do two things at once.

What Is a Vegetarian Thanksgiving Menu?

A vegetarian Thanksgiving menu is the full holiday meal rebuilt so the center of the table holds a vegetarian main instead of a turkey, with the sides, the sauces, and the dessert chosen to sit around it. For the host, the hard part is not finding vegetarian Thanksgiving recipes, since there are more of those than anyone could cook in a decade; it is deciding how many dishes go on the table and which single one gets carved. Thanksgiving for vegetarian guests goes wrong at the level of shape rather than the level of the recipe, which is why this menu fixes the proportions first: five sides, two mains, one dessert.

Two Mains Do the Work One Turkey Used to Do

Thanksgiving runs on abundance, so the instinct when someone is vegetarian at Thanksgiving is to answer with volume. More bowls, more color, more of the vegetarian Thanksgiving foods that were already going on the table. Volume and a center are not the same thing.

One turkey used to do three jobs at once.

It held the visual middle of the table, it got served rather than passed, and it put something on every plate that counted as dinner. Any vegetarian menu for Thanksgiving has to cover all three, and a single dish rarely covers them alone. Thanksgiving vegetarian meals are judged by what sits in the middle, not by how many bowls surround it.

Why Five, Two, and One

• Five sides: enough to fill the plate and the expectation, with the oven still able to hold all of it. Six starts crowding plates and pushing dishes onto a second surface.
• Two mains: one carved centerpiece for the middle of the table, one plated alternative for the guest who wants the familiar shape.
• One dessert: made once and made well, rather than three half-finished pies competing for the same fifteen minutes of attention.
• One count, taken first: ask who is eating vegetarian before you buy anything, because the answer decides whether main two is a platter or a per-person plate.

That count is worth getting in writing. Our guide to how to ask guests about dietary restrictions has the phrasing that gets a straight answer three weeks out, which is the last point where a menu can still change shape rather than gain a dish. Vegetarian Thanksgiving menus that work are built from that number instead of adjusted around it in the final week.

Carving is the job hosts underestimate. A main that slices, such as a lentil and millet roast bound so it slices without falling apart, reads as dinner in a way that a scoop out of a casserole dish rarely manages.

Centerpiece Picks That Hold the Middle of the Table

Main one has one job, which is to be the dish everybody looks at when they sit down. There is no single vegetarian recipe Thanksgiving hangs on, but the centerpiece comes closest, because it replaces the picture people already carry of the holiday. Vegetarian Thanksgiving food gets judged here first, before anybody has tasted anything.

The pick here is a whole roasted pumpkin, stuffed and cut open at the table. A whole stuffed pumpkin filled with rice, vegetables, nuts, and cranberries roasts inside its own shell for about an hour and a half, arrives looking like an object rather than a portion, and gets carved in front of the whole table.

• Buy a medium pumpkin about eight inches across, the size the recipe is written for, and check that it sits flat on the counter before you fill it.
• Roast it on the pan you plan to serve it from, since a filled pumpkin rarely survives being moved twice.
• Stuff it the day before with freshly cooked, quickly chilled rice, wrap it in foil, and refrigerate it raw; the recipe warns against reheating it once baked, so it bakes on the day.
• A butternut squash Wellington fills the same slot when you want something that slices into clean rounds.

Whichever Dish Takes the Slot, It Stays One Dish

Thanksgiving vegetarian dishes multiply on their own, and the discipline of this menu is that the centerpiece slot has exactly one occupant. A second showpiece does not add abundance, it splits attention, and both dishes come out looking smaller than either would alone.

The table can carry some of the load too. Fall table centrepiece ideas such as mini pumpkins and seasonal branches can frame the table, but the stuffed pumpkin is the centerpiece, so anything competing with it moves before the plates go down.

Turkey Alternatives for the Guest Who Wants One

Main two exists for the person who came for a turkey and would like something in its place. That is a real request rather than a failure of imagination, and Thanksgiving vegetarian recipes answer it two ways: a stuffed vegetable served one per plate, or a named substitute shaped like a roast.

The pick here is a wild rice stuffed acorn squash, halved and roasted with mushrooms, and written to be prepped ahead and heated just before serving. One half per guest, plated rather than passed, so a vegetarian guest receives an individual portion instead of a spoonful from a communal dish.

• The stuffed-vegetable route: acorn squash halves, delicata rings, or portobello caps, each filled and plated individually so nobody has to reach across the table for their own main.
• The named-substitute route: a Tofurky-style roast comes with its own oven times and a broth baste, and it reassures the guest who wants the word turkey somewhere on the menu.
• The choice between them: ask what the guest is missing. Someone missing the ritual of carving wants the roast; someone missing a hot savory plate wants the squash.

Both fill one slot. Putting a roast and a stuffed squash and a lentil loaf on the same table turns the menu back into a pile, which is the outcome this shape exists to prevent.

Which Thanksgiving Sides Are Already Vegetarian, and Which Need a Swap?

Four of the five are already there. Thanksgiving vegetarian sides divide cleanly: sweet potatoes, roasted brussels sprouts, glazed carrots, and fresh cranberry sauce contain nothing that has to be replaced. Stuffing is the one that quietly does, and gravy carries the same stock problem even though it is not one of the five sides.

What Makes Thanksgiving Food Vegetarian

What makes Thanksgiving food vegetarian on this menu comes down to a short list of checks, and chicken stock is the culprit in the two big ones. Swapping mushroom stock for chicken stock fixes both the stuffing and the gravy, and dried porcini gives a stuffing more depth than poultry stock does.

Dish	What to check	The fix
Stuffing	Chicken stock, sausage, cooking inside a bird	Mushroom or vegetable stock, baked in a dish
Gravy	Chicken stock, drippings, standard Worcestershire	Vegetable stock, a no-drippings base, vegetarian Worcestershire
Pie crust	Lard in a store-bought crust	A butter or shortening crust
Whipped topping	Gelatin	Check the label or whip cream
Sprouts, carrots, cranberry sauce	Nothing	Already vegetarian

Sausage is common in family stuffing recipes, and stuffing cooked inside a bird is not vegetarian whatever went into it. Handle stuffing and gravy, then check the pie crust for lard and the whipped topping for gelatin, and the whole menu stays vegetarian without anyone at the table registering a substitution.

The Five Sides, Slot by Slot

1. Stuffing: a vegetarian stuffing made with mushrooms and vegetable stock; the mushroom stock from three days out works in its place. It is the vegetarian Thanksgiving recipe that repays a rewrite of the family version.
2. Sweet potatoes, one way only: maple-glazed sweet potatoes for the sweet fork, or a sweet potato gratin for the savory one. Running both on one table is a lot of sugar for a single meal.
3. Roasted brussels sprouts: halved, cut side down, 425°F until the flat faces go dark. They carry the bitter note the rest of the plate needs.
4. Glazed carrots: the tonal contrast to the sprouts, sweet and soft against bitter and crisp, and the side that reheats without complaint.
5. Cranberry sauce: fresh cranberry sauce with orange zest, twenty minutes start to finish, and it keeps up to a week in the fridge, so it can be made three days ahead. It is the acid that cuts the richer dishes beside it.

Choosing vegetarian sides for Thanksgiving gets easier once the two mains are fixed, because the sides only have to fill the gaps the mains leave. Five sides that get finished beat seven that get picked at and cleared.

Cranberry has a second life away from the plate. Non-alcoholic cranberry drinks for the holiday table carry the same cranberry and orange pairing into the glass.

Dessert Is One Decision, and Pumpkin Pie Usually Wins

One dessert. Pumpkin pie is the pick, because it is the dessert the holiday already expects and it needs no explanation at a vegetarian table. Dessert is the course where being vegetarian on Thanksgiving costs you nothing at all.

A classic pumpkin pie fills a single crust with pumpkin, eggs, and cream or evaporated milk, so it is vegetarian as long as the crust is. A lard crust is the version that is not, which is worth checking if the pie is arriving from somewhere other than your own oven.

• Pecan pie is the alternate when somebody at the table does not eat squash in any form.
• Apple pie is the wildcard, and it reheats best if dessert slides past its slot in the evening.
• Check a store-bought crust for lard and any whipped topping for gelatin before either one reaches the table.

Vegetarian recipes for Thanksgiving run thin on dessert for a good reason, which is that nearly all of it already qualifies. The work is choosing one and letting it be the only sweet thing anybody is offered.

Something warm to drink does more for the end of a meal than a second pie. Cozy non-alcoholic fall drinks carry a table from dessert into the slow part of the evening.

Your Cooking Schedule, Three Days Out to the Table

Work backwards from the moment the pumpkin gets carved. A vegetarian Thanksgiving feast of eight dishes has one oven and one stovetop between them, and the schedule is what keeps that arithmetic from turning into a scramble.

Recipes for a vegetarian Thanksgiving hold up well to make-ahead work, which is the advantage this menu has over a turkey. Our holiday dinner party planning guide covers the budget and timeline side of the same week.

What Gets Made on Which Day

1. Three days out: make the cranberry sauce and the mushroom stock. Both keep in the fridge, and both take the stovetop out of contention later.
2. Two days out: buy the pumpkin and the squash, and cube the bread for the stuffing so it dries properly overnight.
3. The day before: cook and quickly chill the rice, stuff the pumpkin and refrigerate it raw in its foil, and roast and fill the squash halves. Make the gravy.
4. Thanksgiving morning: bake the pie first while the oven is empty, then put the stuffing in behind it.
5. The last two hours: the pumpkin goes in for its hour and a half, the squash halves join it to heat through, and the sprouts and carrots roast while the pumpkin rests before carving.

Gravy does not have to wait for the last ten minutes. Sue Moran’s make-ahead cider and sage gravy is built without drippings and gets better as it waits in the fridge. Use the vegetable stock the recipe allows and a vegetarian Worcestershire, since the standard kind contains anchovy, and the whole job moves to the day before.

Frequently Asked Questions

What goes in a vegetarian Thanksgiving menu?

Five sides, two mains, and one dessert. The sides are stuffing, sweet potatoes, roasted brussels sprouts, glazed carrots, and fresh cranberry sauce. Main one is a carved centerpiece such as a stuffed roasted pumpkin, and main two is a plated turkey alternative. Pumpkin pie closes it.

What can vegetarians eat instead of turkey on Thanksgiving?

A stuffed whole squash or pumpkin, a stuffed vegetable served one per plate, or a named substitute such as a Tofurky-style roast. Pick by what the guest expects: the named substitute reassures traditionalists, while a whole roasted pumpkin carved at the table reads as the centerpiece the meal was built around.

Is Thanksgiving stuffing vegetarian?

Usually not, though one swap fixes it. Bread, herbs, onion, celery, and butter are all vegetarian; chicken stock, sausage, and giblets are the three things that are not. Use mushroom or vegetable stock in place of chicken stock, and bake the stuffing in a dish rather than inside a bird.

How many side dishes for a vegetarian Thanksgiving?

Five. Thanksgiving expects abundance, and five sides deliver it without crowding the plate or the oven. The template is one stuffing, one sweet potato dish, two vegetables with one roasted and one glazed for tonal contrast, and one cranberry sauce. A sixth side usually gets reheated after everyone has already served themselves.

When should I tell my Thanksgiving host I’m vegetarian?

Three weeks out, in a warm message: “Wanted to flag that I’m vegetarian. Happy to bring a centerpiece dish so you don’t have to plan around me.” Three weeks gives a host room to adapt the menu rather than redesign it, and the offer removes the awkward part.

What dessert is best for a vegetarian Thanksgiving?

Pumpkin pie. It is the dessert the holiday already expects, it is vegetarian when made with a butter or shortening crust, and it lands as the real thing rather than a substitution. Pecan pie is the alternate and apple pie the wildcard. Pick one and skip the dessert table.

Continue Reading:

More On Vegetarian Dinner Party

• Vegetarian Dinner Party Menu That Wins Over Skeptics
• 12 Vegetable Side Dishes Worth a Second Helping
• Vegan Dinner Party Menu Built Around Five Swaps

More from The Gourmet Host

• Holiday Dinner Party Planning Guide: Menus, Budget, and Timeline
• Fall Table Centrepiece Ideas for Cozy Gatherings
• Non-Alcoholic Cranberry Drinks for Every Holiday Table
• Cozy Non-Alcoholic Fall Drinks for Autumn Hosting
• How to Ask Guests About Dietary Restrictions: Scripts

Explore TGH Categories

• Set the Scene
• Drinks and Bar
• Plan the Meal
• Engage with Guests
• Games and Toasts
• Tools and Techniques
• Why We Gather

Share: