1920s Murder Mystery Dinner Party Guide

Share:

There’s a reason the 1920s never stop coming back. The glamour of the 1920s — speakeasies hidden behind unmarked doors, flapper dresses catching the light, jazz music filling a smoky night — is the kind of atmosphere that makes an ordinary evening feel cinematic. Add a murder mystery to that setting, and you’ve got an evening your guests will talk about for months.

A 1920s murder mystery dinner party combines immersive storytelling with curated food and drink, themed décor, and the kind of social energy that only a lot of drama and a whodunit can produce. Whether you’re a seasoned host or planning your first murder mystery, this guide covers everything: the game, the menu, the scene, and the flow of the evening.

At a Glance

• A 1920s murder mystery dinner party blends Jazz Age atmosphere with interactive gameplay — guests play characters, gather real clues, and test alibis to identify the guilty party.
• The speakeasy menu centres on vintage cocktails like the Bee’s Knees, elegant canapés, and art-deco nibbles that guests can eat between rounds.
• Setting the scene requires dim lighting, jazz music (think Duke Ellington, Louis Armstrong, Bessie Smith), and period-inspired décor like gold accents and feather centrepieces.
• Choosing the right game depends on your group size, comfort with roleplay, and whether you want a kit-based or freeform format.
• First-time hosts can run a polished evening with a boxed murder mystery kit contents and this step guide.

What Is a 1920s Murder Mystery Dinner Party?

A 1920s murder mystery dinner party is a themed evening where guests dress in Jazz Age attire, assume fictional characters, and work together to solve a scripted crime over the course of a meal. The 1920s speakeasy setting — the height of Prohibition, crime bosses, secret bars, and hot jazz — provides the perfect backdrop for intrigue, deception, and a great time.

Why the 1920s Is the Perfect Murder Mystery Setting

The Roaring Twenties were defined by contradiction: exuberance and secrecy, wealth and crime, glamour and danger. According to Smithsonian Magazine’s history of Prohibition, the era’s underground culture created a world where everyone had something to hide — which is exactly the tension a murder mystery needs.

The 1920s theme also gives guests a clear, exciting dress code: flapper dresses, pinstripe suits, feathered headbands, suspenders, and Mary Pickford-era waves. Costumes aren’t just decoration — they’re the first act of stepping into character, and they make the entire party more immersive from the start.

Choosing the Right Murder Mystery Game

The game is the engine of the evening. Your choice determines the structure, the level of roleplay, and how much preparation you’ll need. Here’s how to pick the perfect game for your group.

• Boxed murder mystery kits: These come with character descriptions, game materials, clue cards, and a solution. They’re ideal for first-time hosts because the structure is built in. Look for kits specifically labelled as a roaring twenties murder mystery party game or 1920s murder mystery game to ensure the theme is integrated into the storyline, not just the packaging.
• Masquerade murder mystery: A masquerade murder mystery adds another layer of intrigue — guests wear masks for the first round, hiding identities while building suspense. It’s a great party format for larger groups where not everyone knows each other.
• Freeform / host-written: For experienced hosts, writing your own scenario gives complete control. Set the scene in a fictional juice joint or hottest hush-hush speakeasy, create your own suspects, and tailor the clue game to your group’s personalities.

Most kits support 6–20 players, and many offer expansion packs for larger groups or younger players. If you’re hosting a bachelorette party or engagement party game night, choose a kit with lighter tone and good clean fun rather than graphic crime content.

Setting the Scene: Speakeasy Décor and Atmosphere

The atmosphere is half the experience. You don’t need a massive budget — you need the right details in the right places.

• Lighting: Dim everything. Use candles, string lights behind sheer fabric, and amber-toned bulbs. The goal is a warm, golden glow that feels like a hidden bar, not a living room. Architectural Digest’s Art Deco styling guidehas period-accurate visual references.
• Music: A curated jazz-age playlist is essential. Think Duke Ellington, Louis Armstrong, Bessie Smith, and early jazz standards. A curated Spotify playlist labelled “1920s Jazz” or “Speakeasy Night” will do the work for you — search Spotify’s jazz-age collections for pre-built options.
• Décor touches: Gold and black are your palette. Add feather centrepieces, cigar boxes (decorative only), vintage-style name tag cards for each character, and a “Password Required” sign on the front door for guests to discover. Maple Mystery Games’s 1920s party décor ideas strike the right balance between authentic and achievable.

The décor doesn’t need to be expensive — it needs to be consistent. When every detail says “speakeasy,” the full immersive experience follows naturally.

The Speakeasy Menu: Cocktails and Jazz-Age Food

The menu is where your 1920s murder mystery dinner party becomes a full sensory experience. Period-appropriate drinks and art-deco nibbles keep the theme consistent and give guests something to savour between rounds of interrogation.

• Vintage cocktails: The Bee’s Knees (gin, honey, lemon) is the quintessential Prohibition-era drink. Add a Mary Pickford (rum, pineapple, grenadine) and a classic French 75. The Spruce Eats’ Bee’s Knees recipe is a reliable starting point. Smithsonian Prohibition cocktail history adds context and additional recipes.
• Elegant canapés: Think smoked salmon on blinis, devilled eggs, shrimp cocktail in glass coupes, and elegant canapés that can be eaten in two bites. Serious Eats’ party appetiser collection has options that feel right for a Jazz Age spread.
• Prohibition-style sips (non-alcoholic): Offer mocktail versions of each cocktail for guests who don’t drink. Honey-lemon fizzes, virgin Mary Pickfords, and sparkling water served in coupe glasses keep the aesthetic without the alcohol. Epicurious’ mocktail collection has several elegant options.

Serve food in stages that align with the game rounds. Cocktails and canapés during the introduction, a main course between the second and third rounds, and dessert during the final reveal. This pacing keeps guests fuelled without breaking the narrative momentum.

How to Host: A Step-by-Step Guide

Here’s the practical step guide we recommend for first-time hosts and experienced entertainers alike.

• 2–3 weeks before: Choose your murder mystery game, send invitations with the theme and dress code, and assign characters. Share character descriptions so guests can plan costumes.
• 1 week before: Finalise the jazz-age speakeasy menu, build your playlist, and gather décor. Print game materials, name tag cards, and any extra copies of character sheets for reference.
• Day of: Set up the space, prepare cocktails, and do a final read-through of the game’s host instructions. Dim the lights, start the music, and welcome guests into the speakeasy.
• During the evening: Guide the game through its rounds, serve food between acts, and keep the energy up. Your role as host player is to facilitate, not dominate — let guests drive the drama toward the final reveal.

Real Simple’s themed party planning checklist is a helpful logistics backbone — use it alongside this guide to manage timeline, shopping, and setup.

For more themed hosting ideas beyond the Jazz Age, our dinner party themes guide covers seasonal, cultural, and interactive options. And if your 1920s evening inspires a more intimate follow-up, our winter theme party ideas pair beautifully with the cozy, candlelit aesthetic.

Frequently Asked Questions

Continue Reading…

More on Dinner Party Themes

• Dinner Party Themes: Creative Ideas for Every Season — Your complete guide to choosing and planning the perfect themed dinner.
• Potluck Dinner Party Themes That Guests Love — Creative shared-meal themes that keep potlucks organised and delicious.
• Winter Theme Party Ideas for Cozy Gatherings — Warm, inviting party concepts for the colder months.
• Fall Themed Dinner Party Ideas and Menus — Harvest-inspired menus and cozy autumn hosting ideas.
• Holiday Dinner Party Ideas Worth Celebrating — Festive recipes, décor, and planning tips for your next holiday gathering.

More from The Gourmet Host

• How to Plan a Dinner Party Menu From Scratch
• Easy Meals for Large Groups
• The Ultimate Dinner Party Checklist

Explore The Gourmet Host Categories

• Set the Scene
• Plan the Meal
• Engage With Guests
• Tools and Techniques

Share: